1 Stars By Glinted8 on 2016-08-15
BEWARE 95% OF THESE REVIEWS ARE FOR THE OLD OVERNIGHTS
All of these reviews are for the old version, not the swaddler overnights. Way to go 2DayDeliver to make it look like these swaddler overnights are a high rated item! Can't believe Pampers discontinued the baby dry extra protection. These are an awful replacement and are as thin as the regular swaddler diapers. I'll be using huggies overnights even though I'm not 100% crazy about them. These are a huge disappointment.
1 Stars By colleen on 2016-08-08
Don't bother, VERY poor replacement for the Extra Protection diapers.
We loved the Pampers Extra Protection Nighttime diapers, and only tried the Swaddlers Overnights because they stopped making them. What a disappointment and waste of money. The new Swaddlers Overnights are very thin and leaked by 3am the first night my son wore them.
1 Stars By Lindsay Chang on 2016-08-08
These are a completely horrible replacement for the discontinued "Extra Protection" diapers. My son had worn the old version every night without a single leak for over a year, and he had leaks all 3 nights we have been using these. They are very thin and obviously lack the extra absorbency channels than the old version had. I compared to a regular "daytime" swaddlers diaper, and there is no discernible difference at all. I will be submitting a complaint to Pampers as well.
UPDATE: When I originally reviewed this product on 8/15/2016, my review was one of only 5 reviews (all 1 star's) listed for the new "Swaddlers Overnights" that were released after Pampers discontinued the "Extra Protection" diapers. 2DayDeliver has since merged the reviews of the absolutely terrible new product with that of the old, very good product. This has given this product a falsely positive rating. Also, I did submit a complaint to Pampers regarding the poor quality of the new version, and all I received for my trouble was a $10 coupon and a ridiculous suggestion to have my 26 lb. son switch to a smaller size to avoid leaks (He wore a size 5, and a size 4 would be much, much too small and would hold even LESS liquid). I instead found 4 boxes of the old Extra Protection diapers on BabiesRUs.com and stocked up for the next several months, which should hopefully take us to an age when he will be peeing less at night!
1 Stars By Brooke on 2016-08-20
The Best Part of Waking Up...
...is definitely not pee and diaper filling all over your floor. I am usually a fan of Pampers, but these are absolutely awful. More often than not, my son leaks through during the night, and every time that happens, the whole diaper explodes when we take it off.
1 Stars By Kathleen Taraska on 2016-08-12
BRING BACK THE BABY DRY OVERNIGHT PAMPERS! These are horrible!
WHY OH WHY did Pampers go and switch from the Baby Dry Overnight Protection to the Swaddlers. These are honestly no different than the daytime swaddlers except they seem to run a tinier bit bigger in size. My son is a big middle of the nighttime pee-er. We would use the baby dry pampers and an additional absorbency pad inside the diaper and he stayed dry every night. The second night in these diapers with the additional absorbency pad, he leaked through the diaper and woke up soaked. Plus...even if these worked, the only distinction between these and the daytime swaddlers is that the Sesame Street character is wearing a little nighttime hat on the diaper. Really?!? How am I supposed to keep these separate from the daytime diapers and make sure that my husband is also using the correct ones for daytime and nighttime when they look so similar? Plus, you are getting fewer diapers for more money! This is a joke! Somebody at Pampers messed up big time with this one!
1 Stars By Biobecca on 2016-12-18
Not the same as before! Disappointed.
I just got on amazon to see if maybe I was mistaken, but it appears that yes these are supposed to be the overnights but they are replaced with an inferior product, likely to save money for the company. They used to be the best nighttime diaper out there, and had I known this was going to happen I would have bought more earlier. The older ones were not only softer and more padded w absorbent lining, the lining was also smoother without mesh so the bottom was pampered all night w softness. Now it's the same mesh as in the daytime one, which is fine for regular changes but not great for an all night 12 hour diaper. I can't tell the difference between this diaper and the daytime ones except for the characters in front have pajamas on and there are moons and stars. I'm very disappointed. Enough to write my first amazon review. ☹️
1 Stars By Tacos Tacos Tacos Tacos on 2016-08-15
These appear to be just the regular daytime diapers but ...
These appear to be just the regular daytime diapers but printed with a sleepy Elmo design. Be prepared to change lots of sheets if you use these at night.
1 Stars By HJB on 2016-08-31
Poor replacement for the previous Baby Dry diapers
My 2DayDeliver subscription to Pampers Baby Dry was changed to these Swaddlers Overnights, but they don't last through an entire night — the outside of the diaper is damp in the morning. These are a poor replacement for the previous Baby Dry model, and they don't seem to be any different from regular Swaddlers, other than the printed pattern on the diapers. I am returning the second box I had ordered and switching to another brand. 2DayDeliver should not have migrated reviews from the previous version to this new model; they are not equivalent products.
1 Stars By Melissa J. Pettit on 2016-08-15
Not happy with baby dry replacement
These are no different than the daytime swaddlers. I miss the baby dry for night time!
1 Stars By M. Sullivan on 2016-10-06
Don't bother. Go with Huggies.
Absolute garbage. We decided to try some overnight diapers because my 19-month-old daughter's diapers were leaking overnight. My wife picked up some Huggies at the store. Since I've been collecting the Pampers Rewards and have the 2DayDeliver Parent account for the 20% savings, I resolved to switch to Pampers as soon as we ran out. The Huggies were awesome. The diaper would be absolutely swollen by the next morning, but her sheets and clothes were totally dry. I estimate it held about 15-20 ounces. As soon as I got the Pampers version, I noticed how slim the diaper itself was. It failed absolutely every time she wore it. I think newspaper would have been as effective. I now have an almost full box of diapers that I have no intention of using and immediately bought Huggies again.